The 90-Point Wine Trap: Why Critic Scores Often Mislead and What to Trust

Sun, 07 Jun 2026 00:00:00 +0000

Walk into any wine shop in 2026 and the shelf-talkers tell the same story. “Wine Spectator: 92 points.” “Robert Parker: 94 points.” “Decanter: 95 points.” The score is everywhere, plastered on bottles, displayed on price tags, repeated on websites, used to justify markup. And for the wine drinker trying to make a decent decision, the score has become quietly useless. Not because critics are dishonest, but because the system has been gamed, inflated, and stretched so far that a 90-point rating now tells you almost nothing about whether you will enjoy the wine.

Wine Critics on Sommo — AI Wine Scanner, WSET Prep & Wine Journal App

The 90-Point Wine Trap: Why Critic Scores Often Mislead and What to Trust